Skip to content
FreedomRankings

Criminal Justice

Criminal Justice by State: All 50 States Ranked

How a state polices, prosecutes, and punishes varies enormously — from incarceration rates and sentencing severity to asset-forfeiture protections and due-process safeguards. This ranking scores all 50 states on criminal-justice freedom so you can see where the system is most restrained and where it is most punitive.

Gulf of America
Less Free
More Free

Score reflects incarceration, sentencing severity, asset-forfeiture protections, and due-process safeguards. Darker green = stronger; click any state for its full breakdown.

Most restrained

Most punitive

All 50 states ranked

  1. 1MAMassachusetts
    10.0A+
  2. 2MEMaine
    9.8A+
  3. 3NJNew Jersey
    9.6A+
  4. 4MNMinnesota
    9.4A+
  5. 5NHNew Hampshire
    9.2A+
  6. 6NYNew York
    9.0A+
  7. 7WAWashington
    8.8A
  8. 8UTUtah
    8.6A
  9. 9RIRhode Island
    8.4A-
  10. 10VTVermont
    8.2A-
  11. 11ILIllinois
    8.0A-
  12. 12CACalifornia
    7.8B+
  13. 13NDNorth Dakota
    7.6B+
  14. 14MTMontana
    7.3B
  15. 15MDMaryland
    7.1B
  16. 16NMNew Mexico
    6.9B-
  17. 17HIHawaii
    6.7B-
  18. 18WVWest Virginia
    6.5B-
  19. 19OROregon
    6.3C+
  20. 20CTConnecticut
    6.1C+
  21. 21NENebraska
    5.9C
  22. 22NCNorth Carolina
    5.7C
  23. 23COColorado
    5.5C
  24. 24IAIowa
    5.3C-
  25. 25PAPennsylvania
    5.1C-
  26. 26KSKansas
    4.9D+
  27. 27SCSouth Carolina
    4.7D+
  28. 28VAVirginia
    4.5D+
  29. 29TNTennessee
    4.3D
  30. 30MIMichigan
    4.1D
  31. 31NVNevada
    3.9D-
  32. 32INIndiana
    3.7D-
  33. 33OHOhio
    3.5D-
  34. 34WYWyoming
    3.3F
  35. 35MOMissouri
    3.1F
  36. 36FLFlorida
    2.9F
  37. 37WIWisconsin
    2.7F
  38. 38SDSouth Dakota
    2.4F
  39. 39KYKentucky
    2.2F
  40. 40GAGeorgia
    2.0F
  41. 41AZArizona
    1.8F
  42. 42DEDelaware
    1.6F
  43. 43TXTexas
    1.4F
  44. 44IDIdaho
    1.2F
  45. 45ALAlabama
    1.0F
  46. 46OKOklahoma
    0.8F
  47. 47AKAlaska
    0.6F
  48. 48ARArkansas
    0.4F
  49. 49LALouisiana
    0.2F
  50. 50MSMississippi
    0.0F

Further reading

Death Penalty States: Which States Have Capital Punishment (2026)

Capital punishment is legal in 27 states, though several have paused executions. Here is the full list, which states have abolished it, and how the map has shifted.

Common questions

Which states have the most lenient criminal-justice systems?

Massachusetts ranks #1 for criminal-justice freedom, scoring 10.0/10 — typically a state with lower incarceration, stronger due-process and forfeiture protections, and less punitive sentencing. The full ranking is above.

Which states have the death penalty?

As of 2026, 27 states allow capital punishment, though several keep it on the books under a governor’s moratorium. 23 states plus DC have abolished it. See our explainer on death-penalty states for the full list.

Which states are the most punitive?

Mississippi ranks lowest on criminal-justice freedom, reflecting higher incarceration, harsher sentencing, and weaker procedural protections.

Where does the criminal-justice data come from?

The criminal-justice score draws on incarceration data, the Institute for Justice’s forfeiture grades, and sentencing and due-process measures. See the methodology page for sources.

More state guides

Second AmendmentEducation ChoiceFourth AmendmentEconomic FreedomDrug PolicyProperty RightsRegulatory BurdenFirst AmendmentReligious Liberty